Fortnightly review: grungy ambassadors, immigrant songs and various metals

A Chinese band in Mongolia

Last week was Mongolia’s biggest festival – sporting and cultural – Naadam.  In the middle of the festivities a big concert was held in Ulaanbaatar’s central Sukhbaatar square.  Unfortunately I only saw half a song from the infamous Gee before his set finished and a dull boy band took the stage.  I missed Chinese rock band Banana Monkey altogether.  The Wall Street Journal have dubbed them China’s grungy ambassadors to Mongolia (luckily we did catch them at another gig the night after – they were a lot of fun).

Immigrant songs

It was recently the 100th anniversary of Woodie Guthrie’s birth.  Denise Sullivan writes how Woodie was “the first contemporary singer to take on the dignity of the immigrant as the subject of a song”.  She draws parallels between that song, ‘Deportee’, and The Clash’s ‘Straight to Hell’.  The latter was famously sampled by M.I.A. in her breakthrough hit ‘Paper Planes’, another song concerned with immigrant experience.

Sludge metal in Georgia (USA) and Death Metal in Iraq

I’d never heard of sludge metal before reading this great article about Savannah band Baroness.  The author reckons sludge, “where the workaday southerner’s music—the blues, country, jazz, and southern rock—melts together in metal’s crucible”, is a response to the conservatism of the southern bible belt.

In other metal news, The Atlantic has an article on death metal in Iraq, where that genre’s traditionally anti-Christian messaging is being adapted to rail against Islam.

Pashto Popstar Murdered

A 24 year old female pop star was shot dead, along with her father, in Peshawar, the capital of Pakistan’s restive Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (previously North West Frontier) province on June 18.  Ghazala Javed was a member of the Pashtun ethnic group that straddles the Afghani-Pakistani border.  She was popular with Pashtuns in those two countries and the diaspora in the Middle East.  Read about Ghazala and the risks that musicians in Pakistan take in this article from the Pulitzer Centre.

A catchy tune from North Korea

The Atlantic has a translation of North Korea’s newest propaganda song, for its new leader, Kim Jong Un.  The male choir sings lines such as “by exploding the mental strength of the united heart of our million citizens, Joseon resounds the marching drums of the powerful, prosperous nation”.

Peter Garrett

I’ve previously written about Australian musician politician Peter Garrett.  This detailed and interesting profile of the man by BBC correspondent Nick Bryant manages to simultaneously talk up Garrett and dismiss his political efficacy (the publication requires subscription but you can do a 30 day free trial).

Advertisements

Bowie, Iggy and the Uyghurs

One of my favourite products of the collaboration between David Bowie and Iggy Pop is the song ‘China Girl’.  Both men did a version: it appears on Iggy’s The Idiot (1977) and Bowie’s Let’s Dance (1983) (hence the incongruous shots of Sydney Harbor in the video).  Both renditions are great.

You can draw any number of interpretations from the song.  Apparently Iggy wrote the lyric while pining after a friend’s Vietnamese girlfriend.  It’s not much of a leap to read it to be about opium/heroin/drugs in general.  The most obvious interpretation though is I think to take it as a commentary on western imperialism, cultural and/or political, in Asia.

The first is about the singer’s obsession with his “little China girl”.  A metaphor for orientalism (in the Edward Said, Western fetishism of the East, sense) is on offer, should you choose to take it.  The West’s historical tendency to infantilise the East and its culture is also emphasised by the tongue-in-cheek oriental style guitar (xylophone too in Iggy’s version, I think) found in the intro and outro.

After the bridge the melody changes, and with it the song’s emphasis.  Now we hear of the destructive nature of the singer’s love:

I stumbled into town

Just like a sacred cow

Visions of swastikas in my head

And plans for everyone

It’s in the white of my eyes……

and

My little China girl

You shouldn’t mess with me

I’ll ruin everything you are

I’ll give you television

I’ll give you eyes of blue

I’ll give you a man who wants to rule the world

So yeah, the west corrupts innocent Asia with its modern ways, tricky technology and greed.  It could all be a bit patronising  if not for the brilliant final line: “And when I get excited, my little China girl says, oh baby just you shut your mouth”.  Patronise at your own peril: China/Asia is neither naive or innocent and can stand up for itself.

China has of course always had imperialist tendencies of its own and I don’t think it’s ever been the reluctant imperialist portrayed in ‘China Girl’.  My current country Mongolia knows all about China’s inclusive approach to geographical self-definition (but I’ll write about Mongolia later when I know more about it), as do parts of my old object of study, northeast India (namely Arunachal Pradesh).  Tibet is near the top of every right-on celebrity’s list of causes and Taiwan and the Spratly Islands continue to be live issues that arguably have the potential to trigger intercontinental war.

The plight of the Uyghurs  in far western China however gets comparatively little attention, so here’s a small introduction to that particular issue.

Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, which borders Russia, Mongolia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, India and of course the rest of China (including Tibet) is a vast, resource-rich area.  It is home to only about 20 million inhabitants.  The largest ethnic group in the area is the Uyghur, a Turkic ethnic group that mainly practices Islam.

Xinjiang has been part of China since 1949.  Before that there were two short-lived and Soviet-backed Islamic Republics of East Turkestan (1933-34 and 1944-49).  Since 1990 there has been an ongoing, and sometimes violent, struggle against Beijing in Xinjiang following a student riot and subsequent crackdown leading to 20 deaths that year.  The East Turkestan Islamic Movement has been the main armed group perpetrating this struggle, while the World Uygher Congress, led by US-based Rebiya Kadeer, is the more acceptable face of Uygher nationalism.

Like Tibet, Xinjiang has been granted the apparent concession of special autonomy.  Also like Tibet, Uygher culture, religion and demographic dominance of the area is under attack.  The Chinese state curbs the expression of the Islamic faith in Xinjiang and in 2009 it systematically destroyed the iconic old city of Kashgar.  Han Chinese are encouraged to invest and settle in the region.

Uyghurs are on my mind because at a visit to the National Museum of Mongolia last week I noticed they had been one of the empires to inhabit the Mongolian steppe some time in the early middle ages.  That fact struck me because I had always thought of the Uyghurs as the victims, not the perpetrators, of imperialism.  I guess all peoples have their ups and downs over history, a fact of which the Chinese are very aware.

%d bloggers like this: